Star and Crescent: News for and by the people of Portsmouth
  • HOME
  • NEWS
  • POLITICS
    • WANTED: PORTSMOUTH SATIRISTS
  • SOCIAL ISSUES
  • CULTURE
    • REVIEWS
    • POETRY
      • POETRY SUBMISSIONS
    • FICTION
  • HISTORY
  • EVENTS
  • ABOUT US
    • Contributors
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Corrections and Complaints
    • Comments Policy
  • YOUNG PEOPLE’S VOICES
Latest
  • [ 11th July 2025 ] Horrors of Nuclear War Confronted at University of Portsmouth Events Culture
  • [ 4th July 2025 ] Island City Voices: Symbolic Phonecalls from Gaza Culture
  • [ 2nd July 2025 ] Protestors Picket Stephen Morgan’s Office After Vote to Proscribe Palestine Action as ‘Terrorists’ Politics
  • [ 27th June 2025 ] Welfare not Warfare: Protest Against Benefits Cuts in Portsmouth News
  • [ 23rd June 2025 ] Portsmouth UCU Branch Votes to Divest from Tesla, Starlink and X Politics
HomeNewsThe Future of Journalism in a Festival: S&C at Byline Festival 2019

The Future of Journalism in a Festival: S&C at Byline Festival 2019

11th September 2019 News, Social Issues
Image by Clara Aguirre, IMPRESS.

S&C recently appeared at the Byline Festival – described as ‘the only festival trying to change the world’ – organised by independent news platform and newspaper, Byline, in partnership with the Frontline Club for journalists.  Editor in Chief Sarah Cheverton reports on the 4 day festival that showcases the need for independent journalism in the UK.

The Byline festival ran from 23-26th August at Pippingford Manor Park, East Sussex, featuring music, comedy, activism and journalism. The themes of this year’s festival included defending democracy, the power of journalism and race and representation, featuring the likes of Carole Cadwalladr, Gina Miller, Bonnie Greer and Hardeep Singh Kohli alongside music from The Feeling, Pussy Riot, Lowkey and Don Letts.

This was my first time at Byline Festival and – although sorry to miss Pompey’s homegrown Victorious Festival – I was far from disappointed and often pleasantly surprised. Most of all, the festival highlighted the importance of independent journalism, and the increasingly urgent need to find a sustainable future for the growing number of independent publishers across the UK.

I was part of a panel called Digital Killed the Journalism Star? The Future of News which also included a range of other independent local and national publishers, including Vanessa Baird, New Internationalist; Paul Hutchinson, Bedford Independent; and David Floyd of Social Spider, which publishes 3 community newspapers. Our chair was Jonathan Heawood, CEO of independent press regulator of IMPRESS. Together we discussed the challenges and opportunities facing independent news publishers in the UK, including the implications of the government’s recent review into the sustainability of journalism and the recent announcement of the government’s Future News Pilot Fund. 

Independent journalism often stands in sharp contrast to the mainstream media – both local and national – much of which is dominated by a small number of companies. A report from the Media Reform Coalition this year revealed that:

…just three companies (News UK, Daily Mail Group and Reach) dominate 83% of the national newspaper market (up from 71% in 2015). When online readers are included, just five companies (News UK, Daily Mail Group, Reach, Guardian and Telegraph) dominate nearly 80% of the market, slightly up from our last report.

In the area of local news, just five companies (Gannett, Johnston Press, Trinity Mirror, Tindle and Archant) account for 80% of titles (back in 2015, six companies had the same share). Two companies have 46% of all commercial local analogue radio stations and two-thirds of all commercial digital stations.

Beyond the domination of the news landscape and a resulting lack of media plurality, the corporate domination of the news poses some serious challenges for democracy, as business interests can often conflict with the public interest. This is compounded by the lack of regulation of the corporate press following the government’s decision to scrap the planned second part of the Leveson Inquiry. The decision to scrap the second part of the inquiry – which had been promised to victims of the hacking scandal by then PM David Cameron – was described by Jacqui Hames (talking to the Independent), former police officer and Crimewatch presenter whose phone was hacked, as follows:

The government’s capitulation once again to newspaper owners and executives, over the cancellation of the inquiry before it had been allowed to finish its work, was an act of extraordinary cowardice.

Extensive criminal activity occurred at some of the country’s most powerful newspapers, yet not a single executive has been held accountable – and now the government will not even allow the agreed and promised public inquiry to finish.

For me, three events on the packed line-up at the Byline Festival captured the challenges facing journalism in the public interest today. Each speaker also highlighted the need for a more even playing field for independent publishers in the UK, in terms of funding and regulation, and greater diversity in representation of marginalised and missing groups in journalism itself, including for women, working class people, and ethnic minorities.

Politics is a Crime Scene: With Carole Cadwalladr and Nick Davies

One of the highlights of the first day was a conversation between Carole Cadwalladr and Nick Davies. Carole Cadwalladr is one of the journalists working on the Cambridge Analytica story and the role of political adverts on Facebook during the Brexit referendum campaign (recently featured in Netflix documentary The Great Hack, while Nick Davies is an award-winning investigative journalist and author of several books, including Flat Earth News, which ‘investigated the flow of falsehood, distortion and propaganda through mainstream news organisations and its devastating impact on the societies around them’.

Nick and Carole’s conversation highlighted the need to support investigative journalism in the public interest and the publications that support it, from mainstream news publishers and outlets, to independents. Speaking from their own experiences of reporting from the hacking scandal to Cambridge Analytica, both speakers highlighted the growing concentration of power among corporations, from digital giants like Facebook and Google to the corporate domination of the mainstream media.

Daniel Morgan Murder: The First Great Hack

The second event at the festival captured the impact of this concentration of power in a terrifying way was a session called the Daniel Morgan Murder: The First Great Hack. The murder of private investigator Daniel Morgan in 1987 has been described by the Guardian as a ‘tortuous story of alleged police and media corruption’ and this panel included Daniel’s brother, Alastair Morgan, journalist Kirsteen Knight, Byline co-founder Peter Jukes and crime writer Jake Arnott.

If you haven’t heard about this story, I’d recommend starting with the excellent podcast Untold, featuring Alastair, Kirsteen and Peter, or Peter and Alastair’s book of the same name. In the panel, Alastair explained how he decided to train as a journalist after the mainstream media failed to cover his brother’s murder and the numerous failed investigations to find his killer(s). Alastair spent years trying to get the mainstream media to cover the story, including the serious allegations of corruption levelled at the Metropolitan Police following Daniel’s murder. This struggle led Peter, Alastair and Kirsteen to create the podcast and later to publish a book of the case. At the panel, Jake Arnott explained he is now working with the trio to create a drama series that will help the public to understand the story and its implications for democracy and justice in the UK.

Diversity in Journalism and Broadcasting Panel

Lastly, I attended a panel on diversity in the media chaired by Byline News Editor, Hardeep Matharu and featuring journalist and founder of the Hacked Off campaign, Brian Cathcart, novelist and broadcaster Bonnie Greer, director of the Centre for Media Monitoring, Rizwana Hamid, and media analyst for Mend – an organisation that ‘helps to empower and encourage British Muslims within local communities to be more actively involved in British media and politics’, Zeeshan Ali.

The panel opened with statistics on diversity and media representation, which have strong implications for media coverage and perceptions of minority and marginalised groups in the UK. In 2018, NCTJ (National Council for the Training of Journalists) reported 90% of journalists are white, and Rizwana Hamid explained that the outcome of this absence has serious implications for reporting on ethnic minorities in the UK, including feeding a culture of hostility against minority groups like Muslims.

A 2017 study by Mend reports:

Since the events of 9/11 and 7/7, media coverage of Islam and Muslims has grown exponentially with the
volume of coverage increasing more than tenfold according to some studies. Unfortunately, this increase
in coverage has been overwhelmingly negative with Muslims regularly portrayed in frames that present
them as homogeneous, threatening, and incompatible with Britain’s values and society.

Bonnie Greer explained how the lack of diversity in the UK mainstream media is compounded by the concentration of ownership, as highlighted by the Media Reform Coalition report above. Newspapers, Bonnie explained, ‘are a rich man’s game’ and the UK mainstream media is, as a result, somewhat of a closed shop, ‘comprised generally of people who know each other’, which makes it harder for minority and marginalised groups to enter. The solution to these issues is not as simple as increasing diversity in national and local newsrooms – though it’s a great start. Bonnie Greer highlighted that the culture of newsrooms must shift at the same time, to give more editorial control to diverse journalists.

Zeeshan Ali from Mend highlighted a theme that came up repeatedly throughout the festival: that the UK media’s system of regulation for the news industry – or arguably, the lack of it – is a huge problem. Most of the mainstream media is regulated by IPSO, a self-regulatory body representing many local newspapers and most nationals set up following the Hacking Scandal and the government’s Leveson Inquiry. However critics of IPSO feel the body is toothless and fails to adequately hold news outlets to account, including the Hacked Off Inquiry, which describes IPSO as ‘both unwilling and unable to act’ in a 2018 report.

An even playing field for independent journalism

Each of these panels highlighted the importance of pluralistic, diverse and independently-regulated journalism in the UK as central to protecting investigative journalism that aims to shine a light on injustice and hold powerful interests to account. Yet the playing field for independent news publishers at a national and local level remains woefully uneven. Public funding from the BBC license fee and private funding from tech giants like Facebook and Google remains concentrated in the hands of corporate news organisations, with limited opportunities for independent publishers – from the likes of OpenDemocracy and the New Internationalist to community news platforms like Star & Crescent – to access funds. At the same time, the growing number of independent publishers signed up to independent press regulator IMPRESS are regulated to a higher standard than the national press, as IMPRESS is the only regulator to have met the standards outlined in the Leveson Inquiry.

The Byline Festival is both terrifying and inspiring: terrifying in highlighting the current limitations of the UK’s mainstream press to empower our democracy, and inspiring in showcasing and celebrating the achievements of independent journalism in the UK. Most of all, it reveals and empowers a growing movement of passionate journalists, publishers and audiences who are keen to safeguard public interest journalism and the vital role it plays in a healthy society.

My verdict? The Byline Festival is a must-add to the calendar of anyone interested in the safeguarding of UK democracy in a time of rapid and controversial political and technological change. I’ll definitely be back next year and I hope to see lots of Pompey people there.

The Byline Festival 2020 takes place at Pippingford Park, West Sussex on 28-31st August. Hyper early-bird tickets are available now at £55 for all three days until 30th September 2019 over at the website. 

 

Find out more

Read

Hacked Off: Thrown to the Wolves: How the absence of press regulation hurts the public

Mend: Media Toolkit and guide to Mend’s Islamophobia awareness exhibition for information on Islamophobia in the media

Media Reform Coalition: Who Owns the UK Media in 2019?

Watch

IMPRESS: CEO Jonathan Heawood reveals the story behind IMPRESS, the UK’s officially recognised press regulator

Hacked Off: IPSO: Toughest Regulator in the Western World?

Carole Cadwalladr: TED Talk, Facebook’s role in Brexit and the threat to democracy 

Untold: Daniel Morgan Murder: the Most Investigated Murder in British History – Pitch for the Podcast

Listen

The Untold Podcast: If you haven’t heard the story of the murder of Daniel Morgan, ask yourself, why? 

OpenDemocracy: Five reasons why we don’t have a free and independent press in the UK and what we can do about it

  • Alastair Morgan
  • Bonnie Greer
  • Brexit
  • Brian Cathcart
  • Byline Festival
  • Cambridge Analytica
  • Carole Cadwalladr
  • Centre for Media Monitoring
  • Daniel Morgan
  • Facebook
  • festivals
  • Google
  • Hacked Off
  • Hardeep Matharu
  • Impress
  • Independent journalism
  • IPSO
  • Jake Arnott
  • Kirsteen Knight
  • Leveson Inquiry
  • Media plurality
  • Media Reform Coalition
  • Mend
  • Nick Davies
  • Peter Jukes
  • Rizwana Hamid
  • Zeeshan Ali
Previous

An American in Pompey: Hopping Aboard Britain’s Railway System

Next

What are the Top 10 Toxic Masculinity Behaviours?

Related Articles

Politics

The Labour Party Split: The View From Portsmouth

8th September 2016 Politics

Our contributing editor Maddie Wallace investigates the local consequences of the biggest crisis in the Labour Party since the formation of the SDP in 1981. As even people living in steel bubbles on Mars will [… read more ]

News

New Documentary Featuring Portsmouth Journalist Asks: Do We Know What’s in our Food?

7th February 2018 News

As vCJD – the human form of Mad Cow Disease (BSE) – hits the headlines again, a forthcoming documentary featuring Portsmouth journalist and campaigner Christine Lord investigates how BSE-infected material entered the human food chain [… read more ]

Editorials

Local News: ‘A Bailout Just for the Big Boys Cannot Be Justified’

14th May 2020 Editorials, Politics

Chris Matheson, Shadow Minister for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport and MP for City of Chester explains why he supports the campaign to #SaveIndependentNews, run by the Independent Community News Network (of which S&C is [… read more ]

Latest News

News

Welfare not Warfare: Protest Against Benefits Cuts in Portsmouth

27th June 2025

Portsmouth and District Unite Community is calling a protest against the savage cuts to Personal Independence (PIP) Universal Credit and Employment Support Allowance (ESA), reports trades unionist and activist Alan Burgess. The protest will take [… read more ]

News

What’s Missing from Local News in Portsmouth? And How do we Fix it?

11th June 2025

S&C Editor Dr Sarah Cheverton shares insights from her PhD research on the local news crisis in her second article for Indie News Week (9th-16th June 2025). Building on her first article about the local [… read more ]

Indie News Week 9th-16th June 2025. No news is bad news.
News

What’s Happened to Local News in the UK and What Does it Mean for Portsmouth?

8th June 2025

This week, to mark Indie News Week 2025, S&C Editor Dr Sarah Cheverton is drawing from her recent PhD research on the local news crisis to talk about the dramatic changes to local news over [… read more ]

Post shows logos for Indie News Week, reading: Indie News Week, 9th-16th June 2025; No news is bad news; and support local news.
News

Local News Crisis, Portsmouth: Sign the Petition to Help Regenerate Independent News

8th June 2025

This week – 9th-16th June – is Indie News Week, showcasing the importance of funding community-based journalism across the UK. The campaign’s organisers, the Public Interest News Foundation, has launched a petition calling on the government to support independent local news publishers and even up the playing field between independent local publishers and the large news corporations that own most of the UK’s local news titles.  [… read more ]

News

Record Breaking £11 Billion is Still Not Enough to End the Special Educational Needs Crisis

17th May 2025

Parents and teachers left ‘overwhelmed’ by the failing SEN system in England’s schools, reports University of Portsmouth journalism student Ivana Domozetska. ‘I will do everything and anything for my daughter to get the support she [… read more ]

Show Your Love!

Follow on Facebook

Stay connected

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

About Star & Crescent

We are an independent news website written for and by the people of Portsmouth. We believe in journalism to create social change. Read more about us here.
Image show logo for Indie News Week, reading "Help Indie News Thrive: No news is bad news.
Pages
  • About Us
  • Contributors
  • Join the S&C Contributors
  • Be a Co-Editor
  • Wanted: Portsmouth Satirists
  • Poetry Submissions
  • Comments Policy
  • Donate
Categories
  • News
  • Politics
  • Social Issues
  • Editorials
  • Events
  • Culture
  • Reviews
  • Fiction
  • Poetry
  • Memoir
  • History
Popular on Star & Crescent
  • The Rubbish State of Recycling in Portsmouth
    22nd February 2018
  • Is Austerity Bad For Portsmouth’s Mental Health?
    13th February 2017
  • Dear Anti-Abortion Protesters: An Open Letter to 40 Days For Life
    5th October 2017
  • The Choke’s on Us: Passing the Buck on Air Pollution in Portsmouth
    13th December 2017
  • The Café in the Park Quietly Replaces the Arts Lodge
    29th August 2017
Find out how to report corrections and make a complaint here.
Star & Crescent is regulated by IMPRESS: The Independent Monitor for the Press CIC.

Copyright © 2017 - 2020 | Star & Crescent | All Rights Reserved